Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

89' BSC kit in 1/29

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    89' BSC kit in 1/29

    So I got my long awaited 89' flat car finally from Oley Valley. It's a combination of a resin, 3d printed and sheet metal parts to build a 89' Bethlehem Steel Company car.

    Overall it's a decent kit from a father and son start up shop that the Dad is trying to keep going after the son's death a couple years ago.

    ​​​​​The 3d prints are overall are decent but the resin casting needs a lot of work and looks like the mold needs replacement.

    I'll keep a build log here and see how the kit goes.
    Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_20240910_161930347.jpg
Views:	423
Size:	149.7 KB
ID:	33872 Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_20240910_155819289.jpg
Views:	117
Size:	70.7 KB
ID:	33871 Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_20240910_160602246.jpg
Views:	424
Size:	93.8 KB
ID:	33870 Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_20240910_162241245.jpg
Views:	118
Size:	184.0 KB
ID:	33869 Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_20240910_160543962.jpg
Views:	119
Size:	78.9 KB
ID:	33868 Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_20240910_160845356.jpg
Views:	429
Size:	44.7 KB
ID:	33867 ​​​​​​​
    Follow along on Facebook as well.
    https://www.facebook.com/groups/424898032713171/

    #2
    The more I study the resin casting in this kit, the more I'm getting frustrated with the quality. The mold clearly needs to be replaced! I don't have a photo right now, but the little lip on the centersill bottom is so full of resin bubbles from RTV ripping out due to the undercut, that I might end up sanding off the entire edge and rebuild with styrene strips.

    Another issue that is popping up is the resin casting and FDM print (bolster and coupler assembly) has about a 1/8" gap between the casting width and the steel underframe piece that is supposed to attach. I'm not sure if I want to completely ditch the resin casting and build up my own underframe out of styrene, or try and clean it up. At this point I wouldn't be recommending this kit to anyone until the QC gets better. I'm in email contact with the company and am waiting for a response.
    Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_20240910_160850428.jpg
Views:	106
Size:	59.9 KB
ID:	33880
    I don't expect a high quality commercial grade kit from a cottage industry but I'm getting a bit annoyed with the whole thing instead of being excited.
    Follow along on Facebook as well.
    https://www.facebook.com/groups/424898032713171/

    Comment


      #3
      I'm either really stupid or really smart...

      Step one, sanded off the horrible centersill flanges on the resin model. Then glued on .080 x .080 strip to rebuild. Way better and faster than trying to sand all the cast resin bubbles off.

      Here comes the what am I thinking part.

      I decided well, I might as well scratch build another flat car alongside the kit and see which one turns out better. Grabbed some .125" styrene from the stock, ran down to the hardware store and grabbed some 1/2" steel tube and some 1/2" flat head screws along with a sheet of 16 gauge steel. Countersunk the screws into the styrene, attached the 1/2" tube and started laying out the details. Once the underframe is done, I'll countersink the plate to the styrene and I should have a nice heavyduty flat.

      Meanwhile, I can keep building the other one.
      ​​​​​​

      ​​​
      ​​​​​​
      Follow along on Facebook as well.
      https://www.facebook.com/groups/424898032713171/

      Comment


        #4
        I forgot to upload pictures last night. Oops.

        Here's the resin bubbles on the centersill that I removed.
        Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_20240913_175434544.jpg
Views:	340
Size:	71.5 KB
ID:	33885
        Then the new replacement.
        Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_20240913_231922582.jpg
Views:	353
Size:	43.6 KB
ID:	33887

        My dumb idea...
        Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_20240913_231840973_HDR.jpg
Views:	93
Size:	72.0 KB
ID:	33886


        Follow along on Facebook as well.
        https://www.facebook.com/groups/424898032713171/

        Comment


          #5
          I have done a couple kits that had the same issue. Only the bubbles feel more ch larger in N. A simple vacuum pot would take care of that in the casting process

          Comment


            #6
            Slow progress on this car as I'm diving into proto photos and videos of details while redesigning the end plate. The plan is to use a straight shank coupler so I can get the slack action and the 'fun' crossed knuckles these cars get when you uncouple on a slight curve.
            https://www.kadee.com/shop-by-catego...g-coupler-only

            Videos such as this have been helpful in looking at details on the underframe, and end beam.
            https://youtu.be/WsHzZJWp-Zs?si=SrIo8hIKS8dPX9yM​
            Follow along on Facebook as well.
            https://www.facebook.com/groups/424898032713171/

            Comment


              #7
              It's so frustrating when you outlay money for what's supposed to be a quality kit only to discover you can do better yourself.
              Keep at it Craig, I feel that your scratchbuild will be a superior quality to the kit build.

              Comment


              • craigtownsend
                craigtownsend commented
                Editing a comment
                I've been in contact with the company and am trying to help them fix the few problems and make it a better kit. From the emails so far they are willing to listen.

              • Russ C
                Russ C commented
                Editing a comment
                Well that's good that they're listening to you, hopefully you get something out of this.

              • Cody
                Cody commented
                Editing a comment
                That's good of you to follow up with the seller like that. It's great that they're listening, and kudos to you for doing something about the defects that's more productive than online flaming.

              #8
              The more I watch and study videos of these F89FH flats, the more I get disappointed in the flat car model I bought. I've got some work cut out for me prior to building the kit as a lot of the underframe won't be accessible once it's all assembled. Not just air brake details, and piping, but structural parts that seem to be missing. https://youtu.be/xpS5nYcpR0c?si=KsMofeWR5niB28bs
              Follow along on Facebook as well.
              https://www.facebook.com/groups/424898032713171/

              Comment


                #9
                I don't know if I'm missing something or it's the design of the car but this looks odd.

                Here's a screenshot grab from the website vs my car. Every video I've watched shows that are a filled in.Click image for larger version

Name:	Screenshot_20241004-220808.png
Views:	67
Size:	131.0 KB
ID:	34181 Click image for larger version

Name:	PXL_20241005_050921142~2.jpg
Views:	66
Size:	48.6 KB
ID:	34182
                Follow along on Facebook as well.
                https://www.facebook.com/groups/424898032713171/

                Comment


                  #10
                  So I'm learning a bit about differences between the 1:1 prototype, the kit, and the production by Oley Valley prior to kit production. I emailed Dave, and he said the open channel is actually prototypical to the BSC cars, and that the initial cars they sent out are prototypically incorrect. Phew. Makes me feel a little better. Also he said there are some slight differences between builders and car numbers. The model represents a RTTX number, while the video I was looking is TTDX number and a different builder. I need to make a decision on what I want to do moving forward with this car. Keep the RTTX number and build as a non cushioned car (which I don't have photo evidence of on the branch) or keep plugging forward on a cushioned drawbar version and modify as needed. I'm leaning toward the modified version already.

                  Dave suggested I get a copy of "The TTX Story" book that describes some of the changes/builds. I found a copy in the University of Missouri St Louis library and am hoping my local library can Interlibrary Loan request it.

                  https://eds.p.ebscohost.com/eds/resu...ZzY29wZT1zaXRl
                  Follow along on Facebook as well.
                  https://www.facebook.com/groups/424898032713171/

                  Comment


                    #11
                    The TTX Story is a 2 book set if I remember correctly. I’ve seen Panza speak at the Chicagoland RPM and his knowledge is amazing… what hitches were used when… when and how decks were patched. The books are an awesome resource.

                    Comment


                      #12
                      I was able to get a copy of the 1995 RMC Aug and Sept articles about the F89F flat series which includes a drawing on the car showing brake pipe arrangements and other details.

                      And, Dave (owner of Oley) also emailed me some scans of drawings of the same series of flats. Not the highest quality, but enough that I can see the parts I need. Lots more work ahead still, but the weather has turned rainy so its workshop building season again.

                      My goal is to have this car done with the load by next Bridgetown RPM in Oct 2025. I've said that before with other projects. Maybe this winter I'll refocus on rolling stock and locomotive projects vs layout buildings.
                      Follow along on Facebook as well.
                      https://www.facebook.com/groups/424898032713171/

                      Comment


                        #13
                        Finally doing something productive. I have some old resin castings of brake parts that I'm practicing my #76 drilling on.

                        First lesson was color contrast. Second was use the hand drill vs the drill press.

                        Lots of light and used some 2x cheater glasses.Click image for larger version  Name:	PXL_20241015_010055034.jpg Views:	0 Size:	57.0 KB ID:	34383 Click image for larger version  Name:	PXL_20241015_005953356.jpg Views:	0 Size:	89.2 KB ID:	34384
                        ​​​​​
                        Follow along on Facebook as well.
                        https://www.facebook.com/groups/424898032713171/

                        Comment


                          #14
                          Got my hands on "The TTX Story" book via interlibrary loan. I've got 2 months to study the books before they get returned.
                          Just a quick glance at TTDX series leads me to believe that most if not all the Breda bus deliveries used TTDX cars based on chain working load limits. The other series of 89FH had lighter chain working weights. TTDX series had 1/2" chain with 11,250 pound working load limits. The weight on the first axle of the busses was 12,470 pounds with a totally weight of 49,500 pounds. Now off to find data on 1/2" chain to see if I can't find something close to scale.

                          Slowly but surely this plan is coming together on modeling these iconic bus deliveries.
                          Click image for larger version

Name:	PXL_20241023_220823507.jpg
Views:	99
Size:	174.7 KB
ID:	34583 Click image for larger version

Name:	PXL_20241023_223455424.jpg
Views:	22
Size:	121.6 KB
ID:	34582
                          Follow along on Facebook as well.
                          https://www.facebook.com/groups/424898032713171/

                          Comment


                          • Paul S.
                            Paul S. commented
                            Editing a comment
                            All the way from the University of Missouri, eh, Craig? That's impressive networking.

                          • craigtownsend
                            craigtownsend commented
                            Editing a comment
                            Nothing I haven't done in grad school a lot! Actually if you have a title of a book and search on Worldcat ( a big international library catalog) and send the specific link to your local library they often can find a copy.

                            The John Barringer RR library is a huge resource and they do a good job of lending out books. I've gotten ORER's I couldn't find, BN motive power annuals in the past.

                          • craigtownsend
                            craigtownsend commented
                            Editing a comment
                            PS,
                            Once i get my hands on these types of books, i often scan them for future reference. This one might take a while. 😂 Or I'll just save the stuff I'm interested in.

                          #15
                          Off to see if the MFCL list can help make sense of this kits underframe.

                          I'm not sure if the videos I'm looking at of RTTX cars are from different builders
                          https://youtu.be/wzSQxyAzIGU?si=huYw3Q6ZU94GW1dB

                          The problem I'm discovering is I have just enough information from the TTX drawings but these cars got built by so many different builders and slightly tweaked each design. The kit is sold as RTTX car while I'm interested in building a TTDX car. The biggest difference in car class is the style and amount of hold down chain. The RTTX cars we were originally with bilevel racks.

                          I'm definitely building my own later so I can represent 2 different versions of cars. I think... 😂
                          Follow along on Facebook as well.
                          https://www.facebook.com/groups/424898032713171/

                          Comment

                          Working...
                          X